Sets its sights too low
I have read many books in juvenile fiction and I am constantly looking for titles that will speak to and inspire students in my class. Some excellent books which are read passionately by my inner city students include Street Pharm, Money Hungry, Slam, and True Notebooks.
I realize that the main character, Tyrell, lives a difficult life, but I was so sad to see that the story essentially condones oral sex among minors. While this may be a reality, I believe it sets our sights too low when we are trying to encourage youth to be safe, responsible, and fight for an education instead of falling into the trap of instant gratification.
This could have been an entertaining story which gave voice to an important perspective. Unfortunately, I believe it will ultimately encourage kids to make choices which are not the best for them. I'm a minority teacher who loves working in liberal Berkeley, but in good conscience, I could not give this book to a student. The author has a nice way with words and dialogue. I look forward to her future work and hope it sets its sights a little higher.
Tyrell's one of the best YA novels I've ever read
This is without a doubt one of the best YA books of 2007. I was utterly convinced by Tyrell's character and situation.
One of my favorite books
I enjoyed reading this book. I could not put this book down. It is very detail and I understood it clearly.
My tenth grader wouldn't put it down!
I purchased this book for my son. He read the first page and wouldn't put it down. He finished it in two days and even read it while snacking at the table. Clearly an absorbing story, I highly recommend this book for your teenaged boy, especially those who have trouble finding an engaging read.
Slightly adult content but okay for older teens.
Realistic and complex characters
I read Tyrell in one day--I couldn't stop reading. This book accurately reflects culture, language, history, and values of an African American family living in a homeless shelter in NY. Some of my favorite issues in the book include: adolescence, relationships with family and friends, foster care system, homeless/poverty, keeping secrets, and struggling to stay in school.
On p. 127 Tyrell shares what teachers and school did for him. This was heartbreaking but true for many students across America.
I will definitely share this book with high school students (Grades 9-12) and encourage them to read it.
(7 reviews)
